"History doesn't repeat… but it rhymes." — Mark Twain
Learn More: The Clean Coal Comeback Just Passed $45M
◉ THE PRESENT
The S&P 500 was trading at 7,747 on Wednesday, another record, after the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported July CPI at 3.4 percent year-over-year — matching expectations and falling from 3.5 percent in June. The economy lost 23,000 jobs last month. Oil sits at $83.70 a barrel. And the market is celebrating. Wall Street has decided the soft landing is here: inflation is gliding lower, the labor market is cooling just enough, and the Fed can start thinking about the other direction. The last time a market this confident ran headlong into a Fed pause with inflation near 3 percent and the economy slowing, the year was 1995.
S&P 500: 7,747 (+0.25%) | CPI: 3.4% YoY | Core CPI: 2.5% | Fed Rate: 3.50–3.75% | WTI: $83.70 | 10Y: 4.70% | July Jobs: −23,000
◉ THE ECHO — JULY 6, 1995
The Chairman Blinked First
The boardroom on the second floor of the Eccles Building still had that Cold War government feel in the summer of 1995 — heavy curtains, a long mahogany table, water pitchers nobody touched. Alan Greenspan sat at the head of it on the morning of July 6th with a problem he'd created himself. Over the previous twelve months, he'd doubled the federal funds rate from 3 percent to 6 percent, the most aggressive tightening cycle in a decade. He'd done it to kill inflation before it arrived. And it had worked. CPI was running near 3 percent. But the cure was starting to look like it might be worse than the disease.
GDP had slowed hard in the first half of 1995. The S&P 500 had gone basically nowhere in 1994, returning just 1.3 percent while Greenspan's rate hikes chewed through the economy. Mexico had blown up in December — the peso collapsed, the Tequila Crisis spread through emerging markets, and the Treasury had to organize a $50 billion bailout package. By spring of 1995, inflation wasn't just stable — it was fading. Greenspan told the FOMC that the risks had changed. The risk wasn't runaway prices anymore. The risk was choking off a recovery that still had room to run.
On July 6th, the committee voted to cut rates by 25 basis points, from 6 percent to 5.75. It was the first easing move in nearly three years. Two governors, Alan Blinder and Janet Yellen, dissented — not because they disagreed with the cut, but on a technical detail about money supply targets. The policy direction was unanimous. The Fed was done tightening.
The market already knew. The S&P 500 had climbed from 460 in January to 554 by the day of the cut, setting record after record — seventy-seven of them by year's end. The index would finish 1995 up 37.3 percent, its best calendar-year performance in two decades. The ten-year yield dropped from over 7 percent in late 1994 to around 6 percent by mid-1995. Money was getting cheaper, the economy was still growing, and nobody was hiring a moving truck for their office just yet. It was, by every measure, a perfect soft landing. The only one that ever really worked.
◉ THE RHYME — WHAT'S IDENTICAL
Both moments share the same intoxicating narrative: the Fed got it right, the landing gear is down, and the runway is clear. In 1995, the narrative happened to be true — for about four years.
◉ THE DIVERGENCE — WHAT'S DIFFERENT THIS TIME
Oil tells a completely different story. Brent crude sat at $17 a barrel in the summer of 1995. Today it's above $89. Greenspan didn't have an energy shock complicating his pivot. Warsh does. The Strait of Hormuz remains disrupted, Houthi attacks just killed six people on a cargo ship in the Red Sea, and gasoline is above $4 a gallon nationally. Every dollar at the pump keeps inflation from falling as fast as the headline number suggests.
Greenspan was cutting. Warsh isn't even there yet. The July FOMC vote was 9-to-3 to hold, with three regional presidents dissenting because they wanted a hike. Fed funds futures are pricing in 4 percent by year-end — not lower, higher. In 1995, the July 6th cut was the confirmation. Today there is no confirmation, only hope.
Warsh is not Greenspan. By mid-1995, Greenspan had been chairman for seven years. He'd navigated the 1987 crash, the S&L crisis, and a recession. Warsh took over on May 22nd, barely twelve weeks ago. His Jackson Hole speech on August 28th will be his first major public test, and the market has no idea what playbook he's running.
The speculative excess came later in 1995. In July of that year, the internet was a novelty and the Nasdaq was a respectable index, not a casino. Today, AI infrastructure spending is already running at hundreds of billions, CoreWeave just more than doubled its revenue, and the Nasdaq is trading at valuations Greenspan wouldn't see until 1999. The bubble that took five years to inflate after the 1995 cuts may already be here.
◉ THE RECKONING — WHAT HAPPENS NEXT
Here is what happened after Greenspan's first cut on July 6, 1995. The S&P 500 was at 554. By the end of the year, it was 615 — a gain of about 11 percent in six months. Two more 25-basis-point cuts followed, one in December 1995 and another in January 1996, bringing the fed funds rate down to 5.25 percent. Total easing: 75 basis points. Not deep. Not panicked. Just enough to tell the economy it was safe to keep going.
And keep going it did. The S&P climbed to 740 by the end of 1996, then 970 by the end of 1997, then past 1,200 by the end of 1998. On December 5, 1996, Greenspan stood up at a policy dinner and asked whether markets were displaying "irrational exuberance." The S&P was at 744. Nobody listened. The market doubled from there over the next three and a half years, peaking near 1,527 in March 2000. The Nasdaq, which had been a respectable index in 1995, hit 5,048 in March 2000 — a fivefold increase in five years.
The soft landing worked. Greenspan was hailed as the greatest central banker who ever lived. But the rate cuts that saved the economy also gave the market permission to believe the Fed would always cushion the fall. That belief became a religion. And when the dot-com bubble finally burst, the S&P fell 49 percent from its March 2000 peak to its October 2002 low of 776. It didn't reclaim that high until 2007. The smart money in mid-1995 didn't fight the rally — they rode it. But the smartest of the smart money understood something most people missed: the soft landing doesn't end the story. It starts the next chapter.
The edge: If Warsh delivers a dovish Jackson Hole speech on August 28th — or if September's data gives him room to pause permanently — the 1995 playbook says this rally has years left in it. The S&P didn't peak for five years after Greenspan's first cut. But the playbook also says that every month the rally continues, the eventual reckoning gets larger. The trade isn't about whether to be in or out. It's about knowing which chapter you're in.
◉ TOMORROW’S WATCH
July PPI lands this morning at 8:30 a.m., and if it echoes the CPI cooldown, the soft-landing consensus gets another brick in the wall. The real test is Friday's retail sales report. In June 1995, retail spending slowed enough to give Greenspan his cover to cut — a pattern worth remembering if Friday's number disappoints.
