Logo
Home
About Us
All Publications
Sign Up
Logo
  • Home
  • Posts
  • The Rhyme: Waller's 50-Basis-Point Bomb Hits a Sinking S&P & Its 2022 Echo

The Rhyme: Waller's 50-Basis-Point Bomb Hits a Sinking S&P & Its 2022 Echo

Four years ago, the same governor used the same tactic on the same type of inflation surprise. The S&P lost 27 percent before it found a floor.

"History doesn't repeat… but it rhymes." — Mark Twain

◉ THE PRESENT

Fed Governor Christopher Waller went on CNBC Wednesday morning and said the words every stock trader had been dreading: he wants a 50-basis-point rate hike in December, not the 25 that markets had priced. Hours later, the FOMC minutes from the October meeting landed, revealing that the decision to hold rates was "a close call" and that two participants had already floated something bigger than 25. The S&P 500 has now fallen six straight days, its longest losing streak since April 2024, and the two-year yield just posted its biggest single-day jump in 19 months. This is not the first time Waller has used a hot inflation print to push the Fed toward a bigger move, and the last time he did it, the market was about to enter a bear market.

S&P 500: 7,323.63 (−6.6% from Oct 6 ATH)  |  6-day losing streak  |  Fed funds: 3.75–4.00%  |  10Y: 5.085%  |  2Y: 4.83%  |  Dec hike odds: 25 bps 96% / 50 bps 4%

◉ THE ECHO — AUGUST 25, 1987

The CPI print hit at 8:30 a.m. on a Friday, and by 8:31 the bond market was already on fire.

June 10, 2022. The Bureau of Labor Statistics released the May consumer price index and the number was 8.6 percent, year over year. Wall Street had expected 8.3. The difference sounds small until you remember that every tenth of a point in CPI represents billions of dollars in repositioning across rates, equities, and credit. S&P 500 futures, which had been modestly green before the number, dropped more than a hundred points in under two minutes. By the close the index had shed 2.9 percent, finishing at 3,900.86. The two-year Treasury yield ripped higher. Traders on the floor at the New York Stock Exchange spent the afternoon staring at screens and saying very little.

Then came Monday, June 13. The Wall Street Journal's Nick Timiraos published a piece suggesting the Fed was now considering a 75-basis-point hike at its meeting that Wednesday — not the 50 everyone had expected. Timiraos was widely understood to be the Fed's preferred channel for leaking policy shifts, so the article hit like a grenade thrown into an already burning building. The S&P 500 crashed 3.88 percent to 3,749.63, officially crossing the 20-percent threshold from its January high of 4,796.56. The bear market was confirmed before lunch.

On Wednesday, June 15, the Fed delivered exactly what Timiraos had telegraphed. Chair Jerome Powell raised the fed funds rate by 75 basis points — from a range of 0.75–1.00 percent to 1.50–1.75 percent — the largest single hike since November 1994. Powell stepped to the lectern and spoke in his usual measured cadence, saying the committee believed "strong action" was needed. Something strange happened next: stocks rallied. The S&P climbed 1.46 percent to close at 3,789.99. The worst-case scenario had arrived, and because it was no longer a mystery, the selling stopped. For one afternoon, anyway.

Behind the scenes, there was one voice that had been pushing hardest for the jumbo move. Fed Governor Christopher Waller would later say that the CPI print "anchored — for me — that we are going to go 75." He meant that the data left him no room to argue for anything smaller. In July he went further, telling reporters he supported another 75-basis-point hike and was open to something even larger. Waller became the committee's most visible hawk — the governor willing to say out loud what others would only hint at through anonymous leaks and careful phrasing.

Four years later, Waller is doing the same thing. Same governor. Same tactic. Same language about being "very, very concerned" about inflation. The only difference is the numbers on the screen.

◉ THE RHYME — WHAT'S IDENTICAL

Same governor, same inflation anxiety, same tactic of publicly forcing the committee's hand before the meeting. The only variable is the size of the number.

◉ THE DIVERGENCE — WHAT'S DIFFERENT THIS TIME
  1. The starting point is higher, not lower. In June 2022, the Fed was hiking from near zero. The fed funds rate sat at 0.75–1.00 percent, and the economy was running hot with stimulus still sloshing through the system. Today the rate is already at 3.75–4.00 percent, which means every additional quarter-point carries more weight. A 50-basis-point hike from here pushes rates to levels not seen since 2025. The pain per basis point is higher when you're already at altitude.

  2. The market isn't in a bear market yet. In June 2022, the S&P had already lost 21 percent from its January high when the 75-basis-point bomb dropped. Today it's down 6.6 percent from the October 6 all-time high of 7,844.52 — a correction, not a rout. That means there's more room to fall if Waller's 50 becomes reality. It also means the positioning is less extreme. In June 2022, shorts were already piled in; today, plenty of fund managers are still long and hoping for a soft landing.

  3. Inflation is stubborn, not spiraling. May 2022 CPI was 8.6 percent and rising. The October 2026 CPI rose 0.4 percent month over month — the Bureau of Labor Statistics could not calculate a year-over-year figure because October 2025 data was not collected during a government shutdown — but the monthly pace still runs well above the Fed's 2 percent target. The case for a jumbo hike is about preventing acceleration, not stopping a fire that's already out of control. That distinction matters because it gives the committee more room to push back against Waller.

  4. Geopolitics are different. In 2022, Russia's war in Ukraine was driving energy prices and complicating the inflation picture. In 2026, the Iran-U.S. conflict has pushed oil back toward the mid-80s after collapsing from triple-digit levels earlier this year. The energy overhang exists in both cases, but the direction is different — oil was surging in 2022 and is bouncing off lows in 2026.

◉ THE RECKONING — WHAT HAPPENS NEXT

Here is what happened after the Fed delivered the 75-basis-point hike on June 15, 2022. The S&P 500 rallied 1.46 percent that afternoon, closing at 3,789.99. The next day it gave it all back, falling to 3,666.77. By Friday, June 17, the index touched an intraday low of 3,636.87. The fear-of-the-hike trade was worse than the hike-itself trade. Once the Fed moved, the uncertainty lifted, and buyers came in off the sidelines.

What followed was one of the most aggressive bear market rallies in recent memory. From that June low around 3,636, the S&P climbed 18 percent in two months, reaching 4,305 by mid-August. Hedge funds that had been net short covered into the rally. Retail traders who had been sitting in cash started buying again. For eight weeks, it looked like the worst was over.

It wasn't. On August 26, Jay Powell stepped to the podium at Jackson Hole, Wyoming, and delivered an eight-minute speech that wiped out the entire summer rally. He said the Fed would bring "some pain to households and businesses" and that history warned against loosening policy too early. The S&P dropped 3.4 percent that day. It kept falling through September and into October, eventually hitting 3,491.58 on October 13 — the ultimate bottom of the 2022 bear market, 27 percent below the January high.

The pattern that emerged was simple but brutal: the market rallied when the Fed removed uncertainty, then collapsed again when the Fed confirmed it had more work to do. The first bounce was tradeable. The second bottom was the real one.

Apply that template to December 9, 2026. If the Fed delivers 25 basis points and signals a measured pace ahead, this six-day losing streak probably ends and you get a relief rally — maybe several weeks of it, like the summer of 2022. If Waller gets his way and the committee goes 50, you may still get a rally on the day, because the worst fear will have been realized and priced. But the question that follows — how many more hikes are coming, and how high does the terminal rate go? — is the question that broke the rally in August 2022. And it's the question nobody on the committee can answer right now.

In 2022, the smart money bought the June hike and sold the August rally. The pattern says the initial reaction to the December 9 decision — whatever the size — matters less than what comes after the first bounce. Watch the two-year yield, not the S&P, for the real tell. If the two-year keeps climbing past 5 percent after the meeting, the rally has an expiration date.

◉ TOMORROW’S WATCH

The KBW Bank Index has now lost ground for six consecutive weeks, its longest skid since 2008. Regional bank stocks led the selling Thursday as the 10-year yield pushed above 5 percent and loan loss provisions climbed. The last time bank stocks fell this long while the yield curve was this inverted was July 2007, four months before Citigroup wrote down $11 billion in subprime exposure and the credit crisis went from rumor to fact.

Recommended for you

View All Publications
caret-right

Top Story Daily

"History doesn't repeat… but it rhymes."

Mark Twain

Quick Links

Home

About Us

All Publications

Subscription

© 2026 Top Story Daily